George Floyd said “I can’t breathe.” He had a knee on his neck for nine and a half minutes, and he said it over and over, and it was true, and it killed him. I am saying it now too. I can’t breathe. My heart isn’t keeping up, I have already been in the hospital, I am headed back, and when I lie down at night I can’t get enough air. I didn’t choose those four words for their history. They are simply the most accurate description available, and accuracy is the only standard I have ever asked anyone to apply.
I have had a knee on me too. Not a police officer’s knee. A town’s. It came down on June 6, 2020, and it never really lifted. For him it was minutes. For me it has been six years: petitions, comment threads, police who wouldn’t take my complaints, a harassment charge nobody bothered to interview me about, a man punching me from behind and his wife finishing the job. Six years of weight, applied a little at a time, while everyone standing around explained that they were only keeping the peace. For most of those years I could still breathe, and it was easy to treat the whole thing as a figure of speech. Then, around August, the breathing went. First the knee, then the breath. Same order as his. Just slower.
George Floyd had a bad heart. The medical examiner recorded it. At trial, the officer’s lawyers argued that his heart killed him, not the knee. The jury rejected that, and they were right. A weak heart does not grant anyone permission to kneel on it. Maybe something was already wrong with my heart before 2020; I don’t know. I do know that six years of sustained pressure is hard on any heart, and mine is the one that ended up in the hospital. I am not saying what happened to me equals what happened to him. He is dead, and I am writing this. But the shape is the same, and that is why I think George Floyd owes me money.
He doesn’t, obviously. Neither does his family, whom I have never contacted and never will. But I have spent six years looking for the right office to hear what happened to my life, and every office directs me to another one. Wrong department, try down the hall, submit a written request, pay this fee. I have become an expert on where responsibility isn’t. So this is an application to the wrong department, filed on purpose. At least I know where I stand with it.
Before all this, I made things. Steel, stone, water, landscape: materials with the courtesy to resist honestly. The fountain and gate on the Bridge of Flowers. The sturgeon for the Culinary Institute of America. Work for UMass and Deerfield Academy. In 2002 I helped Paul Forth install the Sojourner Truth plaques in Northampton, and later the polished black stones shaped like Africa on the Bridge of Flowers. I won’t claim I’ve never been an asshole; nobody who works with power tools and other people can claim that. I’m claiming there was a whole life before the label, and a lot of people were part of it.
On June 6, 2020, there was a George Floyd vigil on the Iron Bridge, near my studio at 44 State Street, and the road was closed for it. I walked toward it. People came at me, told me to leave, and closed in around me, and only then did someone start filming. The video went up on Facebook. So the audience got a man already reacting and never saw what he was reacting to. It’s like starting the movie after the match is struck and asking who brought the fire. After that day, I wasn’t a sculptor anymore. I was that guy, the one from the vigil. One video outweighed thirty-five years of work. Floyd got the same treatment from both directions: one side needed a saint, the other needed a criminal, and the actual man was too complicated for either. What survived both campaigns was one sentence, because it was the one nobody could dispute. I never imagined, standing on that bridge, that his sentence would someday be mine.
The official side went the way official things go. The police declined to take my complaints directly. In 2021 a sergeant received a single email about me, wrote in his report that talking to me doesn’t work, and suggested she go to court. In March 2023 she did. Two officers, who by their own account already knew of “prior incidents,” went to her driveway and listened to her version of three years, starting with June 6, 2020. The next day she had a harassment order, and I was charged with criminal harassment based on the eight incidents she had documented. Every judgment in that report is hers, copied in as if it were a finding: I acted “maliciously,” I caused her “emotional distress.” There is no paragraph where anyone asks what I have to say, because nobody asked. The order was vacated once the audio was played, and the court found no probable cause. When I asked for the records, the price was more than I could pay, which is a polite way of keeping a door closed while technically leaving it open. Meanwhile rent stayed on schedule and steel kept costing money.
After the court found no probable cause, I went to the police chief. He told me he trusted his officers. Fine. A chief is supposed to back his people. Then I went to the detective directly, and he told me I had gotten due process. So now the chief and the detective are both telling me I got due process. Here is the process I got: two officers in one driveway, one side of the story, and a criminal charge with my name on it. Nobody ever called me. The only hearing I had was the one where I had to show up and defend myself, and I won it. If that’s due process, it’s the kind where they accuse you first and find out later whether anybody bothered to check. I believe it violated my civil rights under the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments, and I’m saying so as plainly as they said the opposite to me.
On November 30, 2025, outside Floodwater Brewing, a man shoved me and then punched me from behind. I got loose, and his wife took over. She beat on me, threw my recording phone into the Deerfield River, and then went back to beating on me. Zachary Livingston witnessed it. The cases ended with admissions to sufficient facts on assault and battery, continuances without a finding, and stay-away and no-contact orders. Eventually I received $429.99 for the phone. I can deposit that. What I can’t deposit is the time: the interrupted weeks, the postponed work, the afternoons that never became productive.
Then the heart. Six months of continuous atrial fibrillation before I finally went to the emergency room, because I couldn’t breathe. About ten days in the hospital on IV amiodarone. Two cardioversions; the first held for a day, the second for three. An ejection fraction of 21%, which means my heart pushes out about a fifth of its blood with each beat, where a healthy one pushes out more than half. I’m still in AFib, with a rate around 130, on amiodarone, carvedilol, and Eliquis, and a blood pressure near 94 over 70. Sitting still is usually manageable. Walking can bring it on. Lying down is worst. A man should be able to stop working and lie down without negotiating with his own chest.
Another cardioversion is scheduled, and an ablation looks close to inevitable. The PA, the cardiology office, and the head nurse are all working to get an answer from the electrophysiologist. They are not the villains here. But while everyone waits for that answer, my heart doesn’t wait with them. Can I prove the last six years put me in the hospital? No, and no doctor has said so. But stress is hard on hearts, and I know what these years felt like from the inside. I believe the knee did this, or a good part of it, and I’m saying so as a belief, because I’ve had enough of people passing off what they believe as what they can prove.
So what am I asking George Floyd for? Enough money that a treatment appointment doesn’t have to compete with an invoice. Enough that when I lie down and can’t breathe, I’m not also lying there thinking I should be at the bench. The real claims went to the real addresses: in August 2026 I delivered presentment letters to Shelburne and Buckland and got them stamped received. That stamp promises nothing. It only proves arrival. I wish more things in my life did exactly what they were supposed to do, even that much.
My design work starts with places nobody is paying attention to: a dead corner, an empty lot, a strip of ground everyone drives past. I study what surrounds it, the history, the culture, the ecology, and design something that lets the place become what it could have been all along. Right now, I’m the underused space. Thirty-five years of skill sitting idle on the corner while everybody drives by.
George Floyd owes me nothing. I turn the page over and figure the steel for the next job: a piece I might already have, a part to order, work I can do sitting down. On one side, a dead man is being asked to pay for events he never directed, because we both said the same four true words. On the other, a living man who can’t breathe lying down is trying to price a job without promising more than his body can deliver. This side has a customer, a job, and an address. I start here.








