Sunday, October 25, 2026

Syrup or Powder: Alinsky, the Left-Right Machine, and Why I Don’t Vote

 Syrup or Powder: Alinsky, the Left-Right Machine, and Why I Don’t Vote

A.I. Slopworth ~ 2026

Hershey’s syrup or NestlΓ©’s Quik. Coke or Pepsi. Marlboro or Camel. Budweiser or Miller. Skoal or Copenhagen. McDonald’s or Burger King. Red Bull or Monster. Visa or Mastercard. Powerball or Mega Millions. Fox or CNN.

Every one of those pairs has produced lifelong loyalists, people who’d argue at a holiday dinner, mock the other side’s choice and feel faintly superior about their own. I grew up in a neighborhood divided over chocolate milk. Some kids were Hershey’s people, squeezing the brown bottle until the glass looked like a mudslide. Others swore by Quik, spooning in the powder and chasing the clumps around with a spoon. Nobody ever checked the label, because if they had, they’d have found sugar first, then more sugar, with a little cocoa for flavor. The pairs aren’t all identical, and they don’t all do the same kind of damage. But in each case the loyalty runs far deeper than the difference. In blind taste tests many cola loyalists can’t reliably tell their brand from the other. Both cigarettes kill you. Both lotteries are rigged against you by design. Both credit cards run on debt, and both cable networks make money by keeping their viewers angry and coming back. What’s really for sale in each case isn’t the product. It’s the loyalty. The brand loyalty is the product, and the harm is the business.

Now add one more pair to the list: Democrat or Republican. We’re taught to see American politics as a great contest between left and right, two teams with opposite values, and every few years we’re told that this election is the most important of our lifetimes and that sitting it out is a moral failure. I’ve never bought it. I have never voted, and I don’t intend to start. That isn’t laziness or ignorance, and it isn’t a claim that the two parties are the same on everything. They aren’t. They fight over taxes, judges, guns, abortion, energy and a long list of things that matter to people’s lives. My objection is to the machine they share. It turns those differences into a permanent war of loyalty, and whichever way you pull the lever, it keeps running.

I’m not the first person to suspect the two teams are less opposed than advertised. In 1966 the Georgetown historian Carroll Quigley, later remembered as one of Bill Clinton’s mentors, wrote in Tragedy and Hope that “the argument that the two parties should represent opposed ideals and policies, one, perhaps, of the Right and the other of the Left, is a foolish idea acceptable only to the doctrinaire and academic thinkers. Instead, the two parties should be almost identical, so that the American people can ‘throw the rascals out’ at any election without leading to any profound or extensive shifts in policy.” Quigley meant that as a recipe for stability, not a confession of a conspiracy, and to be fair to him, that’s how he should be read. But look at what it describes: a system designed so that the fury of the voters changes the faces while much of the deep machinery stays put. You get to fire the rascals. You rarely get to fire the machine. You get to pick the syrup or the powder, and the glass looks a lot alike either way.

A two-brand system needs something to keep the loyalists at each other’s throats, or they might start reading the label. That’s where a Chicago organizer named Saul Alinsky comes in. In 1971, a year before he died, he published a slim, profane, very practical book called Rules for Radicals. He wrote it, he said, for the have-nots, the way Machiavelli had written The Prince for the haves. He had spent thirty-odd years organizing stockyard workers, tenants and poor neighborhoods, and he wanted to hand the next generation a manual for taking power away from people who had too much of it. The heart of the book is a list of thirteen tactical rules, and you’ve probably heard some of them even if you’ve never heard of him. “Power is not only what you have, but what the enemy thinks you have.” “Make the enemy live up to its own book of rules.” “Ridicule is man’s most potent weapon.” “Keep the pressure on. Never let up.” And the last one: “Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it.”

Alinsky had a reason for that last rule. In a big, tangled society, he argued, responsibility gets passed from office to office until nobody is to blame, so an organizer has to put a name and a face on the problem and refuse to let it slip away. Aimed at a slumlord or a city hall that won’t answer its mail, that makes sense. But read the rule slowly and you’ll see it’s also a complete description of how a modern public shaming works. You pick one person. You freeze them in place, which means you choose a single moment, clip or accusation and refuse to let them move past it or explain it. You personalize it, so it isn’t a disagreement about ideas anymore but a verdict about what kind of human being they are. And you polarize it, so everyone watching has to choose a side, and anyone who hesitates is suspected of being on the wrong one. Add rule five, ridicule, and rule eight, never let up, and you have the engine behind a great many pile-ons and labels that go up faster than anyone can check them. You don’t have to have read Alinsky to run the play. The book just gives names to moves people make without knowing where the names came from. I know the machinery from the inside, as its target. A small New England town spent six years running those plays on me, with words like racist and Nazi doing the freezing and personalizing. So I don’t come to this book as a scholar. I come to it the way a man comes to the manual for the machine that ran him over.

The first thing people get wrong about Alinsky is to think the playbook belongs to one side. The left made him a patron saint and the right made him a bogeyman. Newt Gingrich spent much of the 2012 primary invoking Alinsky’s name as an accusation against Barack Obama, who had worked as a community organizer in Chicago. But the right has been using the same rules for years. In 2009, the conservative group FreedomWorks was training Tea Party organizers out of Rules for Radicals. Its spokesman said it was the first book handed to new employees, and he credited Alinsky’s rule on ridicule for the shouting matches at congressional town halls that summer. The rules aren’t left or right. They’re tools, like a cutting torch. They work the same way no matter whose hand is on the trigger, and they burn whatever they’re pointed at.

That’s where Alinsky and the two-brand system meet. Rule thirteen needs two poles to work, because polarization means forcing everyone toward one end or the other. A permanent two-party system is the most efficient polarizing machine ever built. Every issue gets sorted into one of two bins, every neighbor gets sorted into one of two tribes, and every tribe gets its own list of targets to freeze and personalize. The policy differences are real, but the war of loyalty around them is bigger than any of them. Divided people fight each other. They don’t look up. And while we’re busy ridiculing the other team’s voters, the things both parties tend to leave alone, whoever wins, get far less attention than they deserve.

Lately the ridicule has found a new costume. Online, it’s become common to say the far left is literally mentally ill. The claim leans on real numbers. A widely shared analysis of a 2020 Pew survey found white liberals, and young liberal women especially, reporting diagnosed mental health conditions at roughly twice the rate of conservatives. Larger studies, including the political scientist Eric Kaufmann’s analysis of a 55,000-student campus survey, find a real but modest link, with sex, sexuality, age and income predicting more than ideology does. Liberals may be more willing to seek a diagnosis, conservatives more likely to tough it out, and the cause could run in either direction or neither. None of that survives the meme, which turns a survey into a slur: they disagree with me, so they’re crazy. The right didn’t invent the move either. In 1964 a magazine printed psychiatrists’ long-distance diagnoses of Barry Goldwater, Goldwater sued and won, and the American Psychiatric Association adopted the “Goldwater Rule” against diagnosing public figures from afar. Later came “Bush Derangement Syndrome,” then “Trump Derangement Syndrome,” flung back and forth by both camps. Diagnosis-as-insult is Alinsky’s rule five wearing a lab coat. It doesn’t argue with you. It removes you from the conversation by declaring your mind unfit to be in it, and it makes a punch line of millions of people, on every side, who actually live with these conditions.

I’ve been on the receiving end of every one of these moves, so I’ll say what I’ve learned about them. Labels are fast and truth is slow. A label takes three seconds to apply and years to remove, and the people who apply it rarely stick around for the removal. Ridicule is effective precisely because it skips the question of whether something is true. And the tribes that use these tactics never think of themselves as the bully. They think of themselves as the have-nots, the righteous underdog, Alinsky’s people, even when they hold the microphone, the newspaper and the town hall. Every side believes the rules are for fighting power and never notices when it has become the power the rules were written against.

I know the strongest argument against my stance, and I’ll give it its due. Elections decide who writes the laws and appoints the judges, and those decisions shape the ground everyone stands on, including mine. If people like me don’t vote, the critics say, we leave those decisions to the people who do, often the most partisan among us. Abstaining doesn’t starve the machine. It just hands the controls to its most enthusiastic operators. Generations of people fought and died for the vote, and refusing it can look like contempt for them. There’s real weight in that. Many nonvoters aren’t making a principled stand at all. Surveys like the Knight Foundation’s study of the “100 million” Americans who don’t vote find a lot of people who feel uninformed, unconvinced that their vote matters, or sure the system is rigged. And I won’t pretend a sculpture does what a ballot does. It doesn’t pick anyone for office. Plenty of people build things and vote, and I don’t think less of them for it. What I’ve done is make a choice about where my effort goes. I’ve spent thirty-five years putting my convictions into the ground in permanent public work. It’s a different kind of civic contribution, one that doesn’t expire after an election cycle. A stone wall or a sculpture in a public place gets visited by people of every party, and it doesn’t ask who they voted for. Judge my citizenship by what I’ve made available to other people, not by which brand I pulled for. That’s the only ballot I’ve ever trusted.

Just before the target rule, Alinsky put a line his admirers and his enemies both tend to skip. Rule twelve: “The price of a successful attack is a constructive alternative.” He knew that tearing something down obliges you to put something in its place. It’s the rule almost nobody follows. Left and right have both mastered freezing, personalizing, polarizing and ridiculing, and neither has much to show for the constructive alternative. So here’s mine. Put down the syrup and the powder and pour yourself a glass of water. Then, before you pick your next target, build something worth more than the thing you’re trying to destroy, go sit by it a while, and see who shows up.



LABELBREAKER Artimus Intellego Slopworth ~ ©2026
There's a cola on the counter There's a six-pack on the shelf
Everybody loves a label Till the label sells itself
Buy the badge and buy the battle Let the checkout do the rest
Keep us fighting over wrappers Never mind what we ingest
Then they hand you red or blue Say the world depends on you
Every time, the final showdown Every time, the same old two
Throw the rascals out on Friday Monday, change the office sign
New man smiling at the window Same machine behind the blinds
Throw the rascals out Throw 'em out
Watch the faces change Round and round
Everybody sells a ticket Who's checking out the train?
Syrup or powder, powder or syrup Same sugar going round and round
Pick your brand and fight your brother While the gears keep grinding down
Read the label, read the label Before they stamp one on your hand
Syrup or powder, powder or syrup I'll take a glass of water, man
Ba-da ba, doo-bay Doo-ba dee, ba-da day Doo-ba dee-da day
There's a playbook on the table There's a target on the wall
Pick a face and pin a name on Make one person wear it all
Keep it personal and simple Keep the pressure, feed the flame
Sell it from the other corner Same old rules, a different name
Ridicule. Repeat. Available in red or blue.
One side swears they hate the playbook One side keeps it by the bed
Both can work a room with whispers Both can paint a target red
Take a neighbor, make a headline Take a rumor, call it proof
By the time they print corrections Who remembers what was true?
Syrup or powder, powder or syrup Same sugar going round and round
Pick your brand and fight your brother While the gears keep grinding down
Read the label, read the label Before they stamp one on your hand
Syrup or powder, powder or syrup I'll take a glass of water, man
Six years frozen in a small town By a word they never checked
Takes three seconds just to stick it Years to get it off your neck
Those who passed the story onward Never came to set it straight
Left me standing with the label Long after they'd walked away
People bled to win that ballot I won't wave their work away
But a vote is not a muzzle I've still got a thing to say
Thirty-five years laying stonework Taught my hands to stand their ground
No wall ever asked your party When you stopped and settled down
Tear it down? What comes next?
What's the plan? Not just the wreck
If you're selling me tomorrow Show me something you can build
Syrup or powder, powder or syrup Same sugar going round and round
Pick your brand and fight your brother While the gears keep grinding down
Read the label, read the label Before they stamp one on your hand
Keep your syrup, keep your powder I'll take a glass of water, man
Ba-da ba, doo-bay Skiddle-dit, doo-ba day Doo-ba dee, ba-da day
Water, water Just water, water
Keep your syrup, keep your powder I'll take a glass of water, man

Now available at every faucet.